A la espera de que se estrene la pelicula en cines, las criticas en USA a la edición en DVD son la mayoria unanimes:

Dvdfanatic:
While the movie itself is very good, the special features (and man are there a ton of them) are what make the 2-disc special edition DVD for Hellboy great.
It may not be the best of its genre, but Hellboy has the mixture of plot and action that make the movie very amusing to watch. The loaded set of special features adds incredible value to the DVD, pushing it over the top. My final verdict: If you love action, Hellboy is an all-around must own DVD.

DVDTalk:
In a nutshell, it's going to be very hard for comic book fans to ignore Hellboy on DVD. Long-time fans of Mike Mignola's excellent work will definitely want to give this disc a spin, as the film does an excellent job of bringing these unique characters to life in grand fashion. If that weren't enough, this DVD takes the experience even further: from a terrific technical presentation of the film to a wealth of bonus features, Hellboy one of the most satisfying comic-related productions of the year. As mentioned earlier, a Director's Cut DVD (and accompanying gift set) will be available later in 2004, but don't let that hold you back from checking this bad boy out. It's a winner in every category, and one of the most pleasant surprises of 2004 thus far! Highly Recommended.

</p>